| Zitate australischer Philosophen J. L. Mackie – Kim Sterelny |
| John
Leslie Mackie 25 August 1917 Sydney – 12 December 1981 Oxford – |
| „Philosophy, to be any good, must be analytic;
but conceptual analysis is not the whole of philosophy. Any genuine
progress with philosophical problems requires the sort of argument that
takes account of alternative possibilities, that formulates suggestions
precisely enough to allow them to be fairly examined and tested, that
pays attention to the meaning of words it uses, and that reflects
critically on its own procedures. But the aim is to make progress with
substantive questions, to apply our concepts to reality or to consider
how far they are applicable, not merely to analyse or clarify those
conceptes themselves.“ S. vii, Hervorhebung H.H. Truth, Probability, and Paradox. Studies in Philosophical Logic (1973) Oxford UP |
| Kim
Sterelny Australian National University (ANU), Sydney und Victoria University, Wellington, |
| „... we
think philosophy is continuous with the natural sciences. On this view,
philosophical theories are conjectures whose fate is ultimately
determined by empirical investigation .... An alternative conception is
to see philosophy as an investigation into conceptual truths proceeding
by thought experiments that probe the way we understand our own
concepts.“ The Representational Theory of Mind. Oxford, 1990, S. ix, zitiert nach: S. 23-24, Frank Jackson: "Armchair Metaphysics", in: Michaelis Michael, John O'Leary-Hawthorne, Hg.: Philosophy in Mind. Dordrecht, 1994. S. 23-42 |